BULLETIN
B-42/00
November 20, 2000
Summary of Proceedings
2000 FTA Motor Fuel Tax Section Annual Meeting
To State Tax Administrators:
SUMMARY The 2000 Annual FTA Motor Fuel Tax Section Meeting was held September 24 through September 27, 2000, in Rochester, New York. This bulletin summarizes the presentations and lists the papers available from the conference. It also summarizes the Motor Fuel Tax Section Annual Business Meeting. Copies of the Resolutions approved at the Business Meeting are attached.
Presiding over the conference was Steven Miller from the Idaho
State Tax Commission. Welcoming the participants to Rochester, New
York, was Arthur Roth, Commissioner of the New York State Department
of Taxation and Finance
General Session - Monday
Harley Duncan, Executive Director, Federation of Tax
Administrators, gave an update on state and local taxation and ways
that the Motor Fuel Tax Section can improve on the current
administration of taxes. He briefly discussed sales, corporation,
individual income, and property taxes and how the administration of
these taxes is changing. He also complimented the Advanced Training
Program, and the ExTOLE and ExSTARS projects.
Arthur Roth welcomed everyone to New York State and offered advice on
what to see and eat (apple pie). He also discussed the improvements
to New York State, including $40 billion in cumulative tax relief,
since Governor Pataki took office. He discussed New York State
becoming a magnet for business because of recent tax relief. He also
talked of efforts the state government is making to make its agencies
more accessible to the public. He commended the Motor Fuel Tax
Section for its efforts in uniformity and for partnering with
industry for the good of everyone involved.
Sherrie Alston, Director of the Office of Transportation Policy
Studies, Federal Highway Administration, gave a brief presentation on
the TEA-21 (Transportation Equity Act) legislation. She encouraged
the states to apply for the available funds in the Surface
Transportation Project (STP Funds) included in TEA-21.
Rich Little, from Fuel Compliance, IRS, discussed the IRS
reorganization taking place. He also gave a demonstration of the new
Acoustic Inspection Device. It is an ultrasonic, non-intrusive device
used to determine what product is contained in tankers.
Ken Duggan, Project Manager, Canadian Fuel Tax Project, gave an
overview of uniformity updates occurring in Canada. Joe O'Gorman
discussed uniformity updates for the U.S. and introduced each of his
co-chairs. Each co-chair gave a brief description of their
sub-committee and what they've worked on during the past year.
Concurrent Sessions - Monday
Two concurrent sessions were repeated throughout the
afternoon.
ExSTARS
One session was an Industry and Government perspective on the
ExSTARS Project. Ron Miller, Manager of Motor Fuel Tax from Ashland
Petroleum LLC, gave an overview on why the ExSTARS project was needed
and how it was created. Industry and government officials came
together to determine the best way to report and verify Motor Fuel
Tax. It benefits industry because it allows all the companies to
operate on a level playing field by reducing tax leakage, providing a
single point of filing, protects federal revenues, and eliminates the
need to tax two party exchanges.
Dave Skinner from the Florida Department of Revenue, discussed the current status of the ExSTARS program. He discussed how the information will be distributed to the states and how they can use this information. The program will be tested beginning 10/2000 and should be implemented fully in the first or second quarter of 2001.
ExTOLE
The session on the ExTOLE Project was presented by Peter Steffens
(state of Florida), Dan Gostage (state of California), Patricia Platt
(state of Kansas), and Gene Williams (state of New York). Due to
unforeseen circumstances, the scheduled mediator, Julian Fitzgerald
(Director, Motor Fuels Tax Division of North Carolina Department of
Revenue) was not in attendance.
A handout was available for all attendees which listed the seven areas of the program and their major functions. Peter, Dan, Patricia and Gene also further elaborated on the expectations of each area of the program. Samples of some of the computer screens were also presented. It was noted that a manual is available which provides additional information on the program, including "required" fields for each area. This is available in hard copy format or through E-mail. A future plan is to have it also available on the FTA Web site. Training is scheduled for February, March, and April 2001. It is recommended that at least three people from a government agency attend the training. The attendees should encompass the departments of audit, compliance/enforcement, management, and information management.
Regional Meetings - Monday
The four regions; Midwestern, Northeastern, Pacific, and Southern,
conducted their separate meetings to review the 2000 activities and
to plan 2001 activities.
General Session - Tuesday
Steven Miller reminded everyone to please complete a critique
sheet for this year's conference. In addition, he added that some of
the resolutions had been changed as a result of the regional meetings
held on Monday. He suggested reviewing them before today's business
meeting.
Ken Duggan, Project Manager of the Canadian Fuel Tax Project, spoke
about the Canadian Motor Fuel Distribution System. He discussed each
aspect that comprises the system (refineries, terminals, bulk
dealers, retail stations, and card locks). Also discussed were sales
volumes, point of fuel taxation and consumption graphs.
Tim Turgeon, Excise Tax Manager of Cenex Harvest States, spoke on the
"Smart Site" Fuel Delivery System. The two areas of discussion were
refined fuel distribution (truck) and Smart Site (tank monitors and
controllers). The area of refined fuel distribution included reasons
"why" and "what is it." Discussion on the Smart Site system included
active states that currently participate, how it works, the benefits
of such a system, and the role of the Co-op's.
Jim Declaire, Excise Tax Manager of Chevron, made a presentation on
Internet Purchasing of Fuel. He supplied a handout, which showed the
four models currently being used through the Internet -- Web site for
advertising, vouchers - priceline.com, marketplace, and storefront.
The use of the Internet creates no new fuel tax issues. However,
there is more opportunity for them to arise because of the increase
in the number of players and transactions.
A welcome and invitation to the 2001 Annual Meeting was made by Debra
Hillmer and Alana Gournea with the state of South Dakota. The meeting
is scheduled to be held September 23-26, 2001, at the Rushmore Plaza
Holiday Inn in Rapid City, SD.
Ron Raven, Ph.D., Counselor of Law and Government Relations, Atlanta,
GA, spoke on his publication "Deliver Us From Evil, Governmental
Responses to Reports of Fuel Tax Evasion." He discussed the evolution
of the subject matter and the steps he followed in completing the
publication. He expressed his belief that more work could be done on
this subject matter and hopes that his publication is just the
beginning.
Steven Miller concluded the general session with the presentation
of several awards and certificates of appreciation.
Concurrent Sessions - Tuesday
Two concurrent sessions were repeated throughout the
afternoon.
Industry Perspective
Doug Burdick, Excise Tax Manager for TransMontaigne Product
Services Inc., gave the Industry perspective on Electronic Funds
Transfer (ACH Debit and Credit system). He also discussed uniformity
issues with regard to EFT. The following issues are currently being
addressed: calculations, dollars and cents inputting, filing period
dates and payment dates, data collection service, and warehousing (5
states still do not offer warehousing).
Beverly Rudy talked about issues of concern to all traders in the
Bulk Transfer System. The four main topics she presented were
licensing, pipelining, term definitions, and access to
information.
Eldon Andrus, from Exxon Mobil, Inc., talked about ease of data
transmission, uniformity, data transmittal methods, EDI
transmissions, the number of different taxes involved in motor fuel,
and the ExSTARS and ExTOLE programs.
David Wright, from BP Amoco, Inc., talked about the states giving
industry the ability to make prior month changes, tax exempt
organizations and getting refunds on the tax paid, and the fact that
state laws differ regarding points of sale reporting
requirements.
Ron Raven, Counselor of Law and Government Relations, Atlanta, GA,
talked briefly about the tax situation with Indians. States need to
look at their laws to be certain that they can collect tax without
violating the Constitution.
Enforcement Efforts
This session was moderated by Joe O'Gorman, Assistant Chief of
the New Jersey Department of Treasury, Division of Taxation. Other
speakers included Paul Sload of the state of Pennsylvania, Butch
Jerrell of the state of Indiana, Lee Williams of the state of
Maryland, and Bob Bray of the state of Ohio.
Joe first invited Suzanne Heidenreich to speak briefly about the
uniformity committee. She discussed the objectives of the committee
and invited all to attend the next meetings.
Paul, Butch, and Lee each spoke about their own state's dyed fuel
program including tax and penalty issues. Questions were elicited
from the audience and there was a good exchange.
The four regions reported on their regional meetings for 2000 and
announced the locations for their 2001 meetings. The MFTS Time and
Place Committee announced the following upcoming meetings:
2001 Rapid City, South Dakota 9/23-26/01
2002 Anchorage, Alaska 9/22-25/02
2003 North Carolina (city not yet determined)
2004 Massachusetts (tentative)
The MFTS Resolutions Committee offered eleven resolutions, all of
which were adopted. The MFTS Nominations Committee nominated Roland
Marr, Manager of Motor Fuel Tax Division, state of Illinois, for 2001
MFTS Chair, and Edward McCormick, Manager, Tennessee Department of
Revenue, for 2001 MFTS Vice Chair. Both nominations were accepted and
approved.
General Session - Wednesday
Sandra Ferance from the state of Michigan, discussed the
legislation behind the fact that Michigan seems so "tight-fisted"
with their information. She also discussed what was available to
other states and how to go about getting the information they needed.
She explained that Michigan has very strict confidentiality laws with
criminal prosecution being the result of any violation.
Dave Skinner from the state of Florida, discussed Disclosure Issues
relating to the ExSTARS program. He wanted to make sure that industry
understands that they have some difficult decisions to make with
regard to disclosure when filing through the ExSTARS program.
Industry determines which states will receive their information free
of the federal disclosure regulations. He also wanted the states to
be aware that they will still get information that is subject to
federal disclosure regulations.
Dan Gostage from the state of California, discussed disclosure
legislation that affects California, and the ExTOLE project.
Originally, they thought that they would be able to share information
with all states. However, with the variety of disclosure agreements
between government and industry, they have found that that is not
true. He stated that when the states download from the ExTOLE
program, it would be very clear which records are subject to federal
regulations.
Larry Hecksher, FTA Liaison, IRS, talked about IRS kerosene
regulations. He presented the exceptions to kerosene tax, and
discussed kerosene tax refunds.
Larry also talked about refund fraud. There are four mechanisms to
apply for a refund: 8849 (file a claim), 4136 (credit on Income Tax),
Line 4 adjustments on company's 720, and blind credit on the 720.
Peter Steffens state of Florida, discussed slip tank tax evasion
issues. He described a station owner in Florida using a slip tank to
carry gasoline from Georgia ($.18 less tax per gallon) to another
station that he owns in Florida. Based on auditing cash businesses
without invoices, they cannot prove he's doing this.
Al Howard, of Al Howard Consultants, talked about the history of
motor fuel and price control. He then encouraged all of the states
and the federal government to make a proactive effort for enforcement
on imports. The U.S. refineries cannot meet the demand for gasoline;
consequently, we will be importing more and more. We need to create
an enforcement system that will be able to handle this increase
before we lose billions of tax dollars.
General Session
Motor Fuel Tax Section Uniformity Updates
Ken Duggan, Project Manager, Canadian Fuel Tax Project
Tim Turgeon, Excise Tax Supervisor, Cenex Harvest States
Jim DeClair, Excise Tax Manager, Chevron
Sandra Ferance, state of Michigan
The Federation of Tax Administrators
Dave Skinner, Revenue Program Administrator; and Ron Miller, Manager, Motor Fuel Tax, Marathon Ashland Petroleum LLC
Patricia Platt, state of Kansas; Peter Steffens, state of Florida; Gene Williams, state of New York; and Dan Gostage, state of California
Ms. Beverly Rudy, Esq., Partner, Sutherland, Abill and Brennan
WHEREAS, this the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section held at the Crowne Plaza Hotel in Rochester, New York, will be remembered as informative and enjoyable, and
WHEREAS, the success of the meeting has been due in large part to the excellent arrangements made, informative program presented, and the generous hospitality provided,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the delegates and
guests at the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax
Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section express their thanks and
appreciation to their hosts, Commissioner Arthur J. Roth, of the New
York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Mr. Larry Keeley,
Director, of the Transaction and Transfer Tax Bureau, Susan Brown,
Cindy Calabrese, Alicia Gagnon, Ted Lackner, Karen Lee, Carrie
Lipfeld, Lynn Mullin, Peter Ramo, Wanda Whitney, Gene Williams,
Marvin Rosenfeld, Peg Gardner, Donna Gentile, Tammy Redding, Sarah
Robinson, Richard Effinger & staff at the Rochester District
Office of the New York Department of Taxation and Finance.
WHEREAS, the proceedings of the formal sessions of this seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, have featured the presentation of timely, interesting and well prepared papers, and
WHEREAS, the exchange of technical and administrative information that has been accomplished in our breakout sessions is one of the principal functions of the meeting,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the members of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, express their thanks and appreciation to Steven Miller from the Idaho Tax Commission, Chair of the Motor Fuel Tax Section, who presided at the sessions, and to the speakers and moderators at the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators, Motor Fuel Tax Section for their contributions to the success of the program.
WHEREAS, the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax
Section established an Executive Board, and
WHEREAS, the Executive Board of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section is comprised of the following positions:
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Section has established a
partnership with the Petroleum Industry to combat Fuel Tax Evasion,
and
WHEREAS, to foster this partnership, the executive board recommends to eliminate the Chair and Vice Chair's positions of the Uniformity Committee and replace the positions with Co-Chairs, with one of the Co-Chairs being a State Representative and the other Co-Chair an Industry Representative with the State Co-Chair being the lead Co-Chair.
WHEREAS, in the absence of the state Co-Chair, the National
Vice-Chair of the Motor Fuel Tax Section shall act as the lead
Co-Chair,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the delegates of the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, endorse the change in the Uniformity Chair and Vice Chair positions.
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies desire to operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the states employ different requirements for the reporting of motor fuel tax information, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Uniformity Committee, Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, has adopted uniform schedules for the reporting of motor fuel tax information, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Uniformity Committee, Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, realizes that in a summary situation on the schedules, the mode of transportation could be various ways, in this situation CE-Summary shall be used,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that CE-Summary be adopted as an additional mode of transportation.
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies desire to operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the states employ different requirements for the reporting of motor fuel tax information, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Uniformity Committee, Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, has adopted uniform schedules for reporting of motor fuel tax information,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the following product
codes be amended or adopted:
Undefined (other) products 092
Blending Components (other) 122
Excluded liquid (mineral oil) 077
Diesel Fuel #4 dyed 153
Diesel Fuel #4 undyed 154
E75 078
E85 079
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies desire to operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the states employ different definitions for various terms that are used consistently throughout the motor fuel industry and in state motor fuel tax administration, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Uniformity Committee, Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, has met and adopted uniform definitions which the Committee recommends to assist states in the exchange of information and to relieve the burden on industry of dealing with multiple definitions for similar terms,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the "Procedure for
adding, deleting, or modifying a definition be adopted as
follows:
Procedures for Adding, Deleting or Modifying a Definition
|
Action By |
Step |
Action |
|
Anyone |
1 |
Submits in writing term to be defined, deleted or
modified to the Chairperson of the FTA Motor Fuel Tax
Section Uniformity Committee, along with an explanation of
why the term should be defined, deleted or modified and
provide a suggested definition if available. |
|
Uniformity Chairperson |
2 |
The request and all submitted documentation is forwarded to the Chairperson of the Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee. |
|
Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee Chairperson |
3 |
Receives the requested action and logs same for reason
of documentation. |
|
Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee |
4 |
Reviews the request and assembles suggestions for discussion with the requestor(s)/representative. |
|
Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee |
5 |
Defines, modifies or deletes the definition. |
|
Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee Chairperson |
6 |
Forwards the new, modified or deleted definition to the Uniformity Committee Chairperson. |
|
Uniformity Chairperson |
7 |
Places the proposed addition, change or deletion on the agenda of the Uniformity Committee for formal adoption. |
|
Uniformity Committee |
8 |
Discusses the requested action and accepts or rejects
the definition as added, deleted or modified. |
|
Uniformity Chairperson |
9 |
If accepted, sends the added/modified or the deleted
definition to the Federation of Tax Administrators -- Motor
Fuel Tax Coordinator to prepare a resolution and update the
FTA definition list. |
|
Fuel Accountability Sub-Committee Chairperson |
10 |
Documents Sub-Committee file as to the status of the request. |
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies desire to
operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the evasion of motor fuel taxes has become a problem over the years that has greatly affected the tax revenue of the states and the ability of the industry to effectively conduct its business, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Uniformity Committee, FTA Motor Fuel Tax Section, has met and adopted the checklist for racing fuel, clear/dyed kerosene and alternative fuels to offer a resource to all taxing jurisdictions who are interested in strengthening their motor fuel tax laws to combat motor fuel tax evasion, and
NOW, THERERORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the following
checklist for racing fuel, clear/dyed kerosene and alternative fuels
be adopted as a resource to all taxing jurisdictions who are
interested in strengthening their motor fuel tax laws.
When considering the taxation or exempt status of racing fuel, the following items should be addressed.
If racing fuel is deemed to be taxable, are there refund provisions for off-highway use.
When considering the taxation or exempt status of kerosene, the
following items should be addressed:
If undyed kerosene is deemed to be taxable, are there refund provisions for off-highway use?
As defined in the glossary, alternative fuels are typically products other than gasoline, gasohol, diesel or kerosene. This section therefore provides cross-references to other sections or separate provisions as necessary for successful administration.
Other licensing requirements that should be considered are:
Surety bonds protect the taxing authorities from major tax dollar losses resulting from bankruptcy or tax evasion. The following bonding requirements and issues should be considered when bonding provisions are written:
Some jurisdictions consider these listings confidential and, if this is the case, the legislation should address this concern and make it legal to distribute these license listings both to licensees and on the Internet.
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies
desire to operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the states employ different requirements for the
reporting of motor fuel tax information, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Electronic Commerce Subcommittee of the FTA Motor Fuel Tax Section has adopted a uniform EDI Implementation Guide for the reporting of motor fuel tax information,
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, North American Combined Reporting Methods, EDI Implementation Guide, ANSI ASC X.12 V4030 be adopted as approved by the Motor Fuel Uniformity Committee on June 24, 2000.
WHEREAS, the petroleum industry and state tax agencies desire to operate in the most effective and efficient manner, and
WHEREAS, the states employ different requirements for the reporting of motor fuel tax information, and
WHEREAS, the Motor Fuel Tax Electronic Commerce Subcommittee of the FTA Motor Fuel Tax Section has adopted a uniform EDI Implementation Guide for the reporting of motor fuel tax information,
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, ANSI ASC X.12 V4010 and prior versions TIA Code list be adopted as approved by the Motor Fuel Uniformity Committee on June 24, 2000.
WHEREAS, the delegates of this the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, recognize the potential importance to both industry and the states of the development of the IRS ExFIRS Project, and
WHEREAS, both the ExSTARS and ExTOLE components of the project will potentially provide state specific data on a more timely basis and more efficiently through electronic submissions,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the states fully support the efficiencies that will result from ExFIRS/ExSTARS/ExTOLE electronic filing by industry, and pledge, to the extent possible, to eliminate a separate duplicate paper filing of that same data by industry to any state.
WHEREAS, the success of the Federation of Tax
Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section depends on the dedication of
many State, Federal and Industry participants, and
WHEREAS, several of these individuals, who have contributed to
the success of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax
Section during the previous years, have recently retired or moved
on,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the members of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section express their thanks and appreciation to Lloyd Wicke, state of Colorado, Jennifer (JJ) Hastings, state of Wyoming, Lyman Spencer, Chevron USA, Jim Emmet, Amoco, Spyros Pappas, Arco, Tracy Halubka, state of Montana, John Aikman, state of Indiana, Mel Hickman, state of Iowa, Rich Anthony, state of Ohio, Tom Snyder, state of Ohio, Floyd Atkins, state of Alabama, Harvey Brooks, state of New Jersey, Barbara Bush, American Petroleum Institute (API), Jan Zahn, ExxonMobil, Ray Grimm, state of Wisconsin, and wish them luck in their future endeavors, and
BE IT FUTHER RESOLVED, that a copy of this resolution be forwarded to these individuals.
The eleven resolutions have been read and have been adopted by the voting membership present at the seventy-fourth annual meeting of the Federation of Tax Administrators Motor Fuel Tax Section, held in Rochester, New York, on September 26, 2000.